Thanks everyone for your helpful tips and for trying to solve this mystery with me! Unfortunately, the case is not yet closed for The Creature of Kapu Cave. However, I did make some progress with your help.
When playing Wiki Tiki, I reached the point where I am wining, and I saved it right before the screen goes to the prize tray. That way, if I won another shark tooth, I could go back to my saved game. Since this seems to be a randomly chosen prize dispenser, it was only a matter of tries until I got both prize trinkets. Voila! The Tiki key chain and the unlucky rock are indeed earned by playing and winning Wiki Tiki.
I also found the code index counter that counts the number of “Easter Eggs” you earned, and this number does towards this award here:
Sadly, getting the Trinkets from the Wiki Tiki game only count to the Trinket award, NOT the Egg award. 🙁
- Look for the actual egg in the scuba activity as Frank in the water
- Take a closer look at the lockers, and check to see if it triggers the Egg counter code
It sounds like a few of you have tried opening up all the lockers (good for you!) but you haven’t found anything exciting in there. Hm, how about while I go and check the index counter in the code on that, you go and try using the Unlucky Rock prize on the lockers…maybe that will do something?
Side note! Dahlia posted another Vine. Enjoy!