Quandary - "Aimed primarily at girls 11 and up this is a great title for pre-teen and early teens and it helps to fill a yawning gap in the computer game arena, featuring a resourceful and clever female protagonist who will lure young players into her investigations."

Kids Domain - "Nancy Drew fans or not, this is a great game for teens! The story is intriguing, the puzzles are hard, and there are many clues to sift through, as not all clues are relevant to the murder. There are many hours of enjoyment here, as it will take a long while to work through this game. "

SuperKids - "Nancy Drew Secrets Can Kill requires patience, attention to detail, good problem-solving skills and a love of investigation. Girls who meet these qualifications will enjoy countless hours of ingenious fun and, with any luck, emerge from their adventure triumphant."