Just Adventure - "Having just helping Nancy solve her eleventh pc adventure, I can soundly predict that Nancy Drew aficionados are in for a treat, and not a trick, this Halloween season…This is probably my favorite Nancy Drew game yet. It has just the right amount of spookiness and some clever puzzles"    

USA Today - "It's no mystery why Nancy Drew series is popular...Score: 4½ stars (out of 5)."

Adventure Gamers - "...this game is solid proof that the series continues to show new vigor with each release.  I would rank Blackmoor as the one of the best of them all, if not the best so far.  The enhanced graphics, more open-minded game play, a return to solid puzzling and a well crafted family-friendly game plot make for a nice piece of gaming."

The Ledger - "...I doubt any male player would be labeled a girlie-man for roaming around Blackmoor Manor...The graphics are well done, and the music and characters fit the mood.  And when you read comments on Web sites like "I think this is the best Nancy Drew game yet," or "I'd like others in the series for Christmas," you know Blackmoor Manor has cast its spell."